Awards // Best Supporting Performance (Musical or Film)
Best Supporting Performance (Musical or Film)
| Year | Actor | Performance |
|---|---|---|
| 2010 | David Dimitruk Sarah Schieffelin | More Than Anything Grease |
| 2009 | Jenny Ruyman Sarah Schieffelin | Once on This Island How to Succeed... |
| 2008 | Isabel Rieser | The Tale of Orpheus |
| 2008 | Eli Epperson | Chicago |
| 2007 | Grace Agnew | Rent |
| 2007 | Samantha Evans | The Three Trees |
| 2006 | Michaela Shuchman | More Than Anything |
| 2006 | Jake Westphal | More Than Anything |
| 2005 | Anna Flynn-Meketon | Aida |
| 2004 | Kristen Dolan | Damn Yankees |
| 2003 | Kate Hopkins | Getting Out |
| 2001 | Sarah Steele | Clueless |
| 2001 | Colin Borden | A Funny Thing… |
| 2000 | Sarah Bonner | Once on This Island |
| 2000 | Adriana Alveario | Little Shop of Horrors |
I feel like I belong to a family outside my home when I'm with people at MacGuffin.
— Shana Knizhnik, alumnus
— Shana Knizhnik, alumnus